Overview
You two collide at the point where detachment meets obsession. Aquarius lives in the head, holds opinions loosely and treats everyone as a fellow citizen. Scorpio lives in the gut, holds opinions like a knife, and picks two people in a lifetime to trust.
The pull is strong because each of you is a mystery to the other. Scorpio cannot get inside Aquarius, which is irresistible. Aquarius cannot figure out why Scorpio cares so much, which is just as fascinating.
The first stretch is intense. Scorpio's attention makes Aquarius feel truly seen, and Aquarius's freedom makes Scorpio want to win it.
And that is the problem. Scorpio tightens the grip as Aquarius pulls away, and Aquarius pulls away more as Scorpio tightens, a loop that neither of you invented and neither knows how to break.
Where this pair works it is because both are stubborn enough to hold on and curious enough to keep learning. Where it fails it is because one of you decided the other was a puzzle to solve, not a person to live with.